Second Annual Popsicle Stick Bridge Building Contest:
A Day of Breaking Bridges
The Sea to Sky Branch second annual popsicle stick bridge building contest took place on Saturday March 9th at Park Royal Mall. It was a day of broken expectations, reining champions and surprise winners.
The branch area was well represented, with most participants coming from the North Shore, but a group braved the elements and drove down from Mount Currie, and a few took the ferry from the Sechelt Penninsula to make it for the competition.
The elementary division testing took place in the morning, with 28 bridges registered for testing. There were some familiar faces from last year's competition. Last year's elementary champion, Marissa Lamb from Gibsons, come with a new bridge design. Marissa seemed disappointed with the performance of her bridge, but she still placed 3rd. Marissa's sister, Kirin Lamb, submitted a bridge for the first time this year, and placed second. I'm sure they'll be challenging other contestants for years to come.
This year's winner was Alexander Stojkovic, a grade seven student from Westview Elementary. His bridge held up a whopping 1010.2 N (227.1 lb)! Congratulations Alexander!
Second place was taken by Brian Hicks from Balmoral High School. First place was reining secondary champion, Cody Dart. Cody's bridge held up 1004.1 N (225.7 lb), almost a 3 times improvement over last year. Cody has another TI-83 plus graphing calculator to add to his collection.
Entries were thin in the open category this year, with only three entries everyone was guaranteed a prize. No wimpy bridges here though; those prizes were earned!
Second place was taken by Theresa Wai, a teacher from St. Pius X Elementary school. She runs a Science and Engineering club at the school and had about 12 of her students enter in the elementary division.
Jesse Martins won, with a bridge that held up 1449.9 N (326 lb)! Jesse, who's a stay at home dad, was surprised himself with the outcome of his bridge design. His goal was to reach 100 lb (about 450 N) and ended up about tripling it! Jesse was picking the brains of our judges for tips and ideas for next year: Jesse, considering a change of career?
See the results from all the bridges at our web site (coming soon).
Thanks to our many sponsors and supporters. Go to our website for links to their web sites!
Testing Equipment: Levelton Engineering and RST Instruments.
Prize Donations: Wood Works! (Canadian Wood Council), Staples and Science World.
Kids activities: GeeringUp! from UBC.
Thanks to Daniel Leonard, a UBC structural student who brought out his huge popsicle stick bridge for display.
Thanks to Marvelous Muffins for deals on the muffins, and the Sony Store who lent us a HUGE video display for the day.
Of course, thanks to all the volunteers who helped out. I couldn't have done it without you!
By Johanna Mantsinen, EIT
Elementary Division
| Name
| Weight
| Load
| Bridge Type
| Failure Description
|
| Alexander Stojkovic |
156 |
1010 |
Single inverted deck truss |
Chord tension failure |
| Kirin Lamb |
162 |
930 |
Inverted triple truss |
Top chord failure of truss |
| Marissa Lamb |
156 |
709 |
Inverted single truss |
Lateral buckling of structure |
| Marielle Aviz |
163 |
655 |
Triple deck girder bridge |
Shear failure |
| Ludwig Hon Coleman |
197 |
626 |
Deck (triple) inverted truss |
Lateral buckling of structure |
| Kathleen Mills |
161 |
541 |
Deck arched truss |
Failure in the support system at abutment |
| Chelsea Terczynski |
152 |
503 |
Parallel chord through-truss |
Top chord lateral buckling |
| Luke Gooding |
159 |
430 |
Deck arch |
Lateral deflection of structure |
| Angus Milne |
130 |
422 |
Deck parallel chord truss |
Dramatic disintegration |
| #3 5th Grouse Pathfinders |
171 |
308 |
Single girder deck |
Shear failure at support |
| Natasha Shigas |
99 |
274 |
Parallel chord deck truss (triple) |
Failure at end diagonal |
| Amanda Rella |
156 |
223 |
Parallel chord through-truss |
Lateral sway of end support frame |
| Nathan Spratt |
146 |
220 |
Triple chord through truss |
Lateral buckling of structure |
| Zoe Atkinson |
99 |
188 |
Deck twin girder bridge |
Flexural failure of girders at third point |
| Justin Wong |
101 |
187 |
Centre girder - deck on girder |
flexural failure of girder |
| Steven Joe |
170 |
186 |
Through truss (without top chord lateral bracing) |
Buckling of unrestrained top chord |
| Dayle Gill |
102 |
185 |
Through truss |
Buckling of top chord |
| Jeffery Chan |
148 |
173 |
Deck twin girder |
Flexural failure of girders at third point |
| Chantel Sutherland |
116 |
128 |
Upstanding girder bridge |
Bending failure at girder |
| Shailen Vallabh |
97 |
117 |
Paralell chord through-truss |
Abutment end bearing point failed |
| Ian Holliday |
148 |
73 |
Through-truss (multiple truss configuration) |
Flexural failure of the central chord |
| Allie Buffone |
230 |
68 |
Deck girder |
excessive deflection |
| Andrew Legge |
100 |
56.3 |
Parallel chord through truss |
Top chord failure |
| Arnold J. Nelson |
153 |
55 |
Through truss (unbraced top chords) |
Buckling of unrestrained top chord |
| #1 5th Grouse Pathfinders |
177 |
40 |
Twin girder |
Shear failure of glued joint |
| #2 5th Grouse Pathfinders |
147 |
40 |
Flat plate bridge |
Support failure |
| Damen Aromann |
155 |
19 |
Trough truss (minus a top chord) |
Catastrophic failure of central joint |
| Jonathan Keitlah |
98 |
11 |
Twin upstanding girder |
Failure of discontinuous beam |
Secondary Division
| Name
| Weight
| Load
| Bridge Type
| Failure Description
|
| Cody Dart |
172 |
1004 |
Inverted single truss (triangular configuration) |
Shear failure in end bearing system |
| Brian Hicks |
156 |
654 |
Through-truss bridge |
Top chord failure at end diagonal |
| #2 5th Grouse Pathfinders |
112 |
327 |
Twin girder deck bridge |
Girder flexural failure at one fifth point |
| Janet Azuma |
142 |
279 |
Assymetrical knee-braced girder bridge - 2 planes |
flex failure of girder at knee point |
| Tasheena Pierre |
161 |
71 |
Upstanding girder bridge |
Flex failure of girders near midspan |
Open Catagory
| Name
| Weight
| Load
| Bridge Type
| Failure Description
|
| Jesse Martins |
175 |
1450 |
Deck truss |
Flexural failure of abutment end support members |
| Theresa Wai |
148 |
629 |
Deck inverted truss bridge |
Separation of the apex of the lower
chords at midspan. |
| James Blake |
132 |
419 |
Deck truss (triple) |
Failure of abutment end bearing
systems, followed by separation of end diagonal from top chord. |
|